Zapier vs Make vs Your Software's Built-In Automations: Which Should You Use?
Updated: 5 days ago
Short answer: Start with the automations built into the software you already pay for, because they're the simplest to set up and maintain. If a job needs to connect two or more apps, Zapier is usually the easiest choice for a non-technical owner, while Make suits workflows with more branches and steps. Choose based on the one job you need done, then compare current pricing for that job.
Search for "Zapier vs Make" and you'll find plenty of feature tables. Most of them skip the question I'd ask first: do you need either one? Many small businesses already pay for tools that can send reminders, follow up with leads and update records on their own. Those features just never got turned on.
So think of this as three choices, not two. Here's how I'd sort them out for a small business, in the order I'd try them.
Option 1: Your software's built-in automations
Before you add a new tool, look at what you already own. Depending on the product and plan, your software may already handle common jobs like these:
A CRM can create tasks and send follow-ups when a lead changes stage
An email marketing tool can send a welcome series to new subscribers
Booking software can send appointment confirmations and reminders
Accounting software can send recurring invoices and payment reminders
Look in your software's settings or help center for words like "workflows," "automations," "sequences," or "reminders."
Best for: Jobs that begin and end inside one app.
Watch out for: Limits on your current plan, and logic that can't reach outside the product. Some features may require a higher tier, so check before you build around them.
Option 2: Zapier
Zapier connects apps with step-by-step workflows called Zaps. Something happens in one app, and Zapier performs actions in others. A new website form can add a row to a spreadsheet, send you an alert and create a CRM contact.
Its main strength is how easy it is to get started. You build from top to bottom in a guided editor, and it supports a very large library of apps, so there's a good chance your tools are covered.
Zapier bills by tasks. According to Zapier's help center, a task is a successful action step. Triggers, Filter and Paths steps, and some built-in tools such as Formatter don't count toward your usage. That makes it easier to estimate your costs, but a busy workflow with many action steps can still add up. Check current pricing against your expected volume.
Best for: Owners who want a dependable connection between two or three apps with minimal setup.
Watch out for: Long workflows that run many times a day, because each successful action counts.
Option 3: Make
Make gives you a visual canvas where each workflow, called a scenario, is laid out as connected modules. You can split a workflow into several routes, loop through lists and add error handling, and you can see the whole thing at once.
That extra control comes with a learning curve. Make's help center says credits are its billing unit, and by default one operation equals one credit, with some AI features using more. Because scenarios can run many operations, it's worth testing a real workflow and watching what it uses before you commit. Check current pricing, too.
Best for: Someone comfortable with a bit of logic who needs branching, data cleanup or several steps in one flow.
Watch out for: Building something so clever that only one person understands it. If that person's away when it breaks, you're stuck.
How to decide in four steps
Step 1: Write down one job
Name a specific job, such as "When someone fills in my contact form, add them to my CRM and remind me to call in 24 hours." If you're not sure which job comes first, use this 3-question test for what to automate first.
Step 2: List the apps involved
If there's only one app, check its built-in automations first. If there are two or more, check whether those apps connect directly. If they don't, you're looking at Zapier or Make.
Step 3: Count the steps and decisions
Write out the workflow on paper. A straight line with a few steps fits Zapier nicely. Lots of "if this, then that" branches, or data that needs to be reshaped along the way, leans toward Make.
Step 4: Estimate monthly runs
Multiply how often the workflow runs each month by the number of steps. Then compare that estimate with current pricing on each tool's site. A rough number will quickly show you whether the free tier is enough or a paid plan makes sense.
A worked example
Here's how a fictional business, Smith Roofing, might sort three jobs:
Appointment reminders. The booking software already does this, so Smith Roofing turns on the feature. No new tool needed.
New web lead to CRM and owner alert. This is a simple line across a few apps, so Zapier is a good fit.
Route leads by service type and town, clean up the data, then assign the right person. This has several branches, so Make could be the better fit if someone's willing to learn it.
Want a quick second opinion on your own workflow? Paste this into your AI assistant:
I run [business type]. I want to automate this job: [describe the job]. The apps involved are: [list apps]. It should run about [number] times a month. Should I use my software's built-in automations, Zapier or Make? Explain your reasoning in plain language, list the steps of the workflow, and tell me what I should confirm in each tool's current documentation and pricing before I decide.
Treat the answer as a starting point, because AI tools can be out of date on features and pricing.
The mistake to avoid
The mistake is choosing a tool before you've defined the job. Owners sign up for an automation platform, poke around for an hour, and then let it sit unused. Or they build a big, complicated workflow on day one and lose trust in it the first time something fails.
Start with one small job that saves time every week. Test it with real data, keep a human review step for anything a customer will see, and write down what it does in plain language. Then add a way to find out when it breaks, because every automation will fail sooner or later. A simple, reliable workflow beats an impressive one that nobody trusts.
Frequently asked questions
Is Make cheaper than Zapier for a small business?
It depends on your workflow. The two tools bill differently, so one may cost less for a short workflow and the other for a long one. Estimate your monthly runs and steps, then check current pricing on both sites.
Can I use Zapier and Make with AI?
Yes, both can connect to AI tools, so a workflow can draft a reply or summarize a form submission as one of its steps. Keep a person reviewing anything that goes to a customer until you trust the output. AI steps may affect your usage, so check how each tool counts them.
Should I switch if I've already built automations in one tool?
Usually not, if they're working. Switching means rebuilding and retesting everything, so make sure you've got a clear reason, such as cost or a feature you need. You can always try the other tool on one new job first.
Build your first automation with help
If you'd rather build this with guidance than figure it out alone, book an AI Quick Wins Session. In 60 minutes, 1:1 on video, we pick the one automation that will save you the most time, choose the right tool for it with the test above, and set it up together. It's $9.99, and you can book any open time. Book your session.
.png)


